Put away the cones

Play dodgeball instead… Read more

Data, Training, and Workout Propaganda

This article by Carl Valle on Mladen Jovanovic’s site is too good not to comment. I don’t want to blog about a blog, so I am going to highlight a few points that resonated the most with me based on my experiences. Read more

Is the Goal of Coaching to Educate or to Train?

I am preparing to teach a class on constraints-based coaching, and spent the weekend looking at different online videos in order to “flip” the classroom. I have returned to the video below several times because of one of its early points about education and training. Read more

High school, AAU, and European club basketball as player development systems

Last week, I wrote about the weekly training schedule for the Unicaja Malaga junior teams. The only comment concerned education. On another site, I saw AAU basketball criticized for its negative impact on education, following upon the ESPN OTL discussion on AAU vs. high school basketball.

My primary purpose is player development, but I wanted to address education first. Unicaja plays its games on weekends leaving weekdays free of travel. Likewise, AAU tournaments are primarily on weekends. During this past high school season, tournaments that attracted out of town teams started on Tuesdays and Wednesdays. One team that played in several out of town, national-caliber tournaments missed at least 11 days of school in December. When I played, a road game meant +/- 30 minutes travel to and from the game, plus arriving an hour early, plus one-and-a-half hours for the game, plus 20 minutes post-game. Rather than a two-hour practice, a weekday road game is a three-and-a-half hour time expenditure. How is club basketball or the European schedule more of a threat to education than the high school season?

As for player development, let’s examine the basic schedules:

High School

During the season, teams play, on average, two games per week. A typical  schedule is Wednesday-Friday. Teams practice three times per week (Monday, Tuesday and Thursday) and sometimes four (Saturday). The average practice is two to two-and-a-half hours. If the teams plays, on average, one home game and one away game per week, and practices three times per week, the average time expenditure is roughly 13-14 hours per week split between three team practices and two games. Some teams add weight lifting — though many do not lift during the season — which could add 2-3 hours of weight lifting to the time commitment.

Club Basketball

During the spring, most club teams practice 1-2 times per week and play a tournament with 3-5 games per tournament on the weekend. Some teams do not practice during the week because they attract players from a wide geographical area (out of state), so they run mini-camps on weekends when they do not have a tournament. On average, let’s say that teams practice once per week and play four games in a weekend tournament. Therefore, the average time expenditure is 10.5 hours plus travel time and dead time at the tournament. Most clubs do not lift weights together.

Due to the lack of practice, many players seek individual training during the week to train their individual skills. Many high schools (at least in California) play year-round, and players have team practices with their high school teams plus spring leagues and/or tournaments.

Unicaja Schedule

Each Unicaja player has two days of individual or position-specific workouts for a total of two hours per week.

The team practices four times for two hours or less for another eight hours.

They work with a strength coach on speed, quickness, agility and strength for no more than an hour on four days per week for, at most, four hours per week.

They play one game on the weekend. Their total time investment is about 18 hours per week plus travel time to the away games.

Analysis

Unicaja’s schedule involves slightly more time than the average high school program that lifts weights and considerably more time than the average club team or high school team that does not lift weights.

The biggest advantage of Unicaja’s system is that one person — the Head Coach — organizes the entire schedule. The assistant coaches, head coach, strength coach and others work together and organize the schedule. If the strength coach thinks the players look fatigued, the coaches can communicate and adjust the schedule or the training.

The problem with the club/high school schedule, especially because many players play for both during the spring, fall and summer, is the lack of communication and coordination. A club coach may give his or her players a weekend off because they are fatigued, but rather than rest, the players play in a high school tournament or work with a personal trainer.

I spoke to a mother a couple years ago when I invited her daughter to a free workout. Her mother was interested, but said she did not have time. She explained that her daughter had two high school team practices per week, two AAU team practices per week, three sessions per week with a “plyo coach,” two workouts per week with a personal trainer in group workouts and a tournament every weekend with her high school team and AAU team. She invested 15 hours per week plus the weekend tournaments. The irony was that when I watched her play  with a college recruiting coordinator, the college coach said that she looked like she could be pretty good if she worked with a good coach!

The problem with her training schedule was that none of the coaches communicated. Her “plyo coach” worked separately from her workout coach and her AAU coach did not communicate with her high school coach. No coach overworked the player by him or herself, but the accumulation of training over time was probably too much (close to 25 hours if you count the weekend tournaments, without a single day to rest).

If looking strictly at the high school schedule versus the Unicaja schedule, Unicaja’s schedule provides several advantages.

  1. Assuming that most coaches do not like to lift weights the day before the game, when can a team lift weights? Monday and Saturday. How productive are workouts the day after a game on the weekend?
  2. The Unicaja schedule incorporates two individual position-specific skill workouts, whereas the high school schedule is all team practices.
  3. The Unicaja schedule provides a day of rest twice per week (Wednesday and Sunday), whereas the high school schedule combines the two off-days (Saturday and Sunday).
  4. With a game only on Saturdays, Unicaja can practice hard Monday, Tuesday and Thursday and have a day for a lighter practice before game day. The high school schedule affords a hard practice on Monday.
  5. With two games per week, coaches spend much of their time preparing for their next opponent on their Tuesday and Thursday practices. With one game per week, Unicaja can use Monday, Tuesday and Thursday for more general practices and Friday to prepare for their next opponent.

The Unicaja training schedule favors player development because of its structure. Meanwhile, the typical high school schedule is geared toward competition and game preparation.

When I argue about various systems, this is my argument. Unicaja’s system favors development through its schedule. It’s not about coaching styles or ability. The schedule provides the time to emphasize player development, whereas the high school schedule is rushed and focused on games.

Secondly, the Unicaja system keeps all parts — players, coaches, strength coaches, trainers — on the same page where they can work together for each athlete, whereas the current high school/club schedule lacks continuity as each segment works as its own entity.

The high school/club schedule puts a heavy emphasis on the player and parents to understand his or her body, understanding his or her training and create an individual program within these different entities to meet the individual’s needs within his various team’s goals and schedules.

I know players who skip club practice to work with trainers because they feel the club practice is useless. I know players who skip high school tournaments for club tournaments because of the better competition. I know players who skip club practices for a high school league game because they feel that games are more important than practices.

Because of their commitments, they are stretched and have to choose, which pits one coach against another.

The Unicaja system eliminates these choices and battles and organizes the training activities in one location with one goal and one commitment for the players. The benefits of the Unicaja system are those that I envisioned for the Elite Development League and see as an improvement over the current system where players go back and forth between high school and club ball and trainers and strength coaches. My goal with the EDL was to present an alternative that negates the pressure that players feel to transfer schools to a better basketball program and creates a more unified development system rather than the current hodgepodge of programs to encourage a more balanced, periodized schedule which emphasizes player development with competition, not just game preparation and competition.

Coaching or Training?

Vern Gambetta has a post titled “Are you coaching them or training them?” Gambetta wrote:

Those who are training the athletes are counting reps, looking at the stopwatch and shouting out times. Those who are coaching are closely observing the athlete, commenting on technique, encouraging and correcting. You can teach a anyone to yell out times or to spot to someone, it is much harder to coach, you have to be fully involved have a plan, see the big picture, understand the context of the exercise or the drill and the training sessions.

Most basketball trainers fit Gambetta’s definition of trainers: they set up a drill and call out repetitions. This goes for those working with kids as well as those working with pros. There is often very little coaching involved with specialty trainers.

Those that are trainers, not coaches are looking for the magic bullet, the secret workout, the short cut to the championship. Coaches understand that there are not any shortcuts and secrets. Coaching is just hard, planned and directed work that accumulates over time to produce the desired performance. Building athletes and teams is an incredible long term commitment that demands total focus and concentration.

By Brian McCormick, PhD
Coach/Clinician, Brian McCormick Basketball
Author, Cross Over: The New Model of Youth Basketball Development
Director of Coaching, Playmakers Basketball Development League

  • What Is A Playmaker?

    Who decided that a point guard has to be small? More importantly, what is a point guard? We expect a point guard to be a leader and have a high basketball I.Q. Why don’t we expect or challenge all players to develop this game awareness? Why rely on only one player? Read more →
  • The PBDL Concept

    English soccer academies wait until players are 11 to play full 11v11 soccer; in Italy, youth basketball players participate in skill-oriented clinics at 6-years-old, but start competitive games at 12. In the United States, kids play 5v5 full court games and compete for national championships when they are 8-years-old.

    Read more →

  • Starting A PBDL

    The PBDL emphasizes learning and development. Presently, players and parents have numerous recreation options - leagues based on fun and equal participation, typically for beginners - and numerous competitive opportunities - teams focused on strategy, game preparation and winning. There are few true development leagues - until now.

    Read more →